Auto.co.za

New Audi A5 (2026) vs Used A4: Which One Makes More Sense in South Africa?

Ntsako MthethwaNtsako Mthethwa19 November 20266 min read
New Audi A5 (2026) vs Used A4: Which One Makes More Sense in South Africa?
1/9

- a lovely, frugal cabin undermined by pricing that only works if you ignore the used market. You shouldn’t.

Introduction

Here’s the short version: I like the new Audi A5, but I’m not convinced I’d buy one new. In South Africa, it’s expensive enough that the used-market maths starts making a lot more sense.

The A5 has effectively taken over from the A4, bringing a new generation, a much more modern cabin and a noticeably higher price tag. Meanwhile, outgoing A4s and previous-generation A5s are sitting on the used market for considerably less.

That makes this less about whether the A5 is a good car – it is – and more about whether you really need the newest one. We’ve looked at current listing data from auto.co.za to find out where the smarter money sits.

Key takeaway: The 2026 Audi A5 is classy and frugal, but a used A4 or B9 A5 delivers most of the experience for around half the price.

Design & Exterior

Audi’s naming shuffle gives the A5 the job the A4 used to do. It’s longer, the boot is now a practical liftback and the overall shape looks lower and more purposeful than before. You’ll know it’s an Audi immediately, even if you have to think twice about which one.

That familiarity works, although Audi hasn’t exactly pushed the design envelope. The Black Edition adds gloss-black trim and darker detailing, and I think it suits the car. Park it next to a BMW 3 Series and the A5 feels calmer, cleaner and a little more grown-up.

Where it sits in the segment

Locally, SUVs outsell sedans comfortably, leaving the A5 to earn attention through design, technology and road manners rather than easy showroom demand. Its liftback tailgate offers a genuine practical advantage over three-box rivals, particularly when you’re loading bulky luggage before an N3 run.

Cabin & Practicality

Cabin quality is where the A5 starts defending its price. The dashboard is screen-heavy but tidy, while the surfaces touched most often feel properly expensive. Material quality across the upper cabin is excellent.

The physical-controls gripe

Audi has ditched the physical climate controls, and I’m still not convinced that’s progress. Try changing the fan speed on the N1 and you’re prodding a screen instead of reaching for a dial you can operate by feel. It looks neat, but it isn’t as intuitive.

The glossy trim around the lower console is another poor choice, picking up fingerprints and fine scratches far too easily. At this price, I’d expect better. Taller drivers may also find the steering wheel partially obscures the top of the display.

Space and boot

  • Rear headroom becomes tight for passengers over about 1.8m tall.
  • Boot capacity is 445 litres, trailing the 3 Series’ 480 litres.
  • There are five seats, four doors and a liftback aperture that accepts awkward cargo more easily than a saloon boot.

If you pack smart, that wide opening makes the luggage area handier than its capacity suggests. I fitted two medium suitcases and a folded pram with 90 mm to spare beside the load. Rear headroom remains the bigger family compromise.

On the Road

The 2.0-litre turbo petrol produces 204hp and 340Nm, enough for a claimed 0-100km/h in 8.0 seconds and a 240km/h top speed. We managed 8.3 seconds in repeatable testing, which feels about right.

It’s not going to set your pulse racing, but there’s enough performance for effortless overtaking. The dual-clutch gearbox is similarly relaxed, favouring smooth shifts over drama. That suits the A5 perfectly: it’s more interested in covering ground quickly and quietly than pretending to be a sports car.

Ride and refinement

Across pockmarked sections of the R21, the A5 remains composed and impressively quiet, although sharp edges still reach the cabin. This generation also feels less nose-heavy than earlier A-badged sedans and closer to its rear-driven rivals in balance. It isn’t as involving as a 3 Series, nor does Audi seem particularly serious about making it one, despite the advertising.

Economy

Claimed fuel consumption is 7.0 L/100km with CO2 of 128 g/km, supplied by a 54-litre tank. Expect high-sixes on an easy highway run and low-eights in town; we observed 8.1 L/100km across a mixed 312 km route. I once watched the trip computer settle near its claim on the N3 at altitude, even after several uphill overtakes. This drivetrain is genuinely efficient rather than merely flattered by its official rating.

Data & Comparison

Local asking prices expose the depreciation problem immediately. New 2026 A5s average around R1.26m and reach R1.6m when heavily optioned, while older examples wearing the same badge dip below R500k.

Price by model year (SA listings)

Model yearTypical asking price
2018R299 900 (median)
2020R439 950 (median)
2021R569 995 (median)
2022R499 972 (median)
2023R634 948 (median)
2025R1 049 950 (median)
2026R1 253 295 (median)

Depreciation and running costs

  • A 2026 car bought near R1.26m projects towards roughly R635k in three years, judging by current 2023 stock.
  • That’s close to half the purchase price gone in 36 months.
  • Five-year total cost of ownership adds around R230 000 to the purchase price.

How it stacks up against rivals

SpecAudi A5 (2026)BMW 3 SeriesUsed A4 40 TFSI (2022)
Power146kW~135kW~140kW
Boot445 L480 L~460 L
Typical price~R1.26mfrom ~R1m+~R500k
0-100km/h8.0s~7s~7.3s

Editorial Focus

Right, so does a 146kW front-driven sedan costing around R1.26m make financial sense when the model it replaces sells used for half as much? On rand-per-power maths, no. You’re paying roughly R6 200 per hp new, compared with closer to R2 600 per hp for a used 2022 A4 40 TFSI. That gap is difficult to explain away.

The used cross-shop nobody runs

Frame the choice honestly. A new A5 costs R1.26m and could be worth R635k in three years. Alternatively, a 2021-2023 A4 or B9 A5 costs R500k-R635k now, after its first owner has absorbed the ugliest part of the depreciation curve. The new Audi A5 vs used Audi A4 comparison isn’t close on cost-per-km. Used wins comfortably, even after allowing for maintenance, Gauteng tolls and the occasional gravel-road scar.

What you actually lose going used

You give up the newest screen technology, liftback body and full factory warranty. Those benefits are real. Yet a 2023 A5 at R634 948 offers similar substance, while a used 40 TDI quattro provides all-wheel-drive traction that a new FWD 146kW car can’t match. The Audi A5 depreciation curve remains this review’s most important figure, and it points away from the new-car floor.

Safety rating

ANCAP · tested 2024

★★★★★ 5/5 adult occupant

Australian-market RHD rating — indicative for SA only where the SA derivative matches the tested safety spec (airbags/ESC/AEB). Official factsheet.

Verdict

Look, the 2026 A5 is a classy, efficient executive sedan trapped on the wrong side of a savage depreciation curve. It’s what the A4 replacement should have been from the start in cabin quality, if not value. Here’s the tiered call.

  • Buy it new: if you want the latest interior, practical liftback and full warranty, and genuinely won’t lose sleep over R625k evaporating in three years.
  • Buy the used B9 A5 or A4 instead: if value leads the decision. A 2022-2023 example at R500k-R635k supplies most of the experience for roughly half the outlay.
  • Cross-shop a used C-Class or 3 Series: if you want rear-drive involvement or a bigger boot at used-market money. Here, the 3 Series comfortably undercuts new-A5 pricing.
  • Wait: if the car must be new, hold out for demonstrator or run-out deals. Early 2025 stock is already appearing used below list price, and those discounts should grow.

Summary

A used-market review of the 2026 Audi A5 in South Africa, covering price, depreciation, cabin quality and the case for buying a two-to-three-year-old A4 or A5 instead. It’s aimed squarely at buyers shopping in the R1m-plus executive-sedan bracket.

Ratings

overall
4.5/5

Pros

  • ✓If you want the latest interior, practical liftback and full warranty, and genuinely won’t lose sleep over R625k evaporating in three years.

People Also Ask

How much is the Audi A5 2026 price in South Africa?▾
The Audi A5 2026 price South Africa starts near R1.08m, while the median asking price is around R1.25m and heavily optioned cars reach about R1.6m. That’s a significant increase over the outgoing A4, sharpening the value debate for local buyers choosing between new and used stock.
Is the new Audi A5 better than a used Audi A4?▾
For technology and warranty, yes. For value, no. A 2021-2023 A4 costs roughly half as much as a new A5 while retaining most of the substance. If depreciation matters more than having the latest screen, the used A4 is the smarter financial decision by some margin.
What is the Audi A5 vs BMW 3 Series verdict?▾
The Audi A5 vs BMW 3 Series contest has a clean split. BMW’s sedan is sharper and provides a larger 480-litre boot, while the Audi feels calmer, richer inside and returns a claimed 7.0 L/100km. Pick the A5 for cabin polish and refinement; choose the BMW for greater driver involvement.
How fast does the A5 depreciate?▾
Very quickly, as many executive sedans do in South Africa. A new R1.26m car projects towards about R635k in three years, or roughly half its original value. Buying a two-to-three-year-old example leaves the first owner carrying the steepest loss.
Is the Audi A5 Black Edition worth it?▾
Black Edition trim looks smart and dominates the current local sample, thanks to its dark exterior detailing. Yet this Audi A5 Black Edition review finds the same touch-control and gloss-plastic frustrations as elsewhere in the range. Buy it for the appearance, not because it cures the A5’s ergonomic flaws.
Where can I find a used Audi A5 for sale in South Africa?▾
Used supply is healthy, with over a hundred adverts nationally. Stock ranges from older Sportbacks near R300k to nearly new Sedans above R1.3m, spread across franchise dealers, independent retailers and chains such as WeBuyCars. Searching used Audi A5 for sale South Africa reveals 2020-2023 examples in the R440k-R635k band, dramatically below new pricing.